Reviews

Star Rating:

***** Brooklyn Boys Pizzeria is rated 4.6 out of 5 stars, based on 74 reviews!

  • *****

    great pizza and service love that place always great to go there and eat and friendly workers and

  • *****

    Great bunch of workers who are extremely friendly. Pizza is good as well as other items on the menu.

  • *****

    Prices are great. Your usual for a little pizza shop. Slices of pizza are huge and really good. We enjoyed a slice before going to the movie. We will be back for sure.

  • *****

    Really good pizza. It's like a neighborhood pizza place. Their white pizza is awesome!!!

  • *****

    Very good pizza. Not too much room to sit but comfortable.

  • *****

    The best new york pizza in boca. Been going there forever.
    Quick service. Yiu can eat outside too.

  • *****

    My friend and I agreed to meet at 1:30 pm on a Friday for lunch. We had the BEST (and I DO MEAN "BEST" eggplant pizza)...it is NOT grilled eggplant on the pizza. It is the breaded eggplant that they use for eggplant parmigiana and cut up into pieces but placed all around the pizza and baked right in with the sauce and mozzarella cheese. Simply delicious! One small pizza was big enough for the two of us, but there are various sizes to choose from if you have an appetite.

    We started off with a house salad which was ice burg lettuce, cucumbers, onion, tomato and choice of dressing. I opted for the Italian vinagrette; my friend as well. Nice crisp lettuce, fresh ripe tomato, ample enough for a side salad and delicious as well. The staff is nice and friendly. It is a small, hole-in-the-wall establishment next to a bank on one side and a nail salon and Starbuck's on the other side.

    A yogurt place is coming soon with a post office there as well, which is currently open. I took a picture of my pizza which I will upload if I can figure out how to do it. (LOL). I've been enjoying the pizza from here for YEARS now even with different owners and now, what would appear, different bakers as well. While I am NOT from New York or even really experienced "NY Pizza" too many times in MY lifetime, THIS pizza ranks RIGHT UP THERE for me as one of the best pizza establishments to get a delicious home-style pie.

  • *****

    Great pizza. Hands down the best in Palm Beach county if you like thin, NY style pizza!

  • *****

    Best crust in west Boca. Love the tomato/basil pie.

  • *****

    The pizza at Brooklyn Boys is outstanding. The crust is crispy, the cheese is melted perfect, and the sauce is light and simple. I order a simple pepperoni and the entire slice was covered in thin slices of pepperoni... Not an inch of piece was missing a pepperoni. I head over to Brooklyn Boys every few weeks for a quick slice of pie on my lunch hour... It never disappoints.

  • *****

    If you are truly looking for NY pizza, recalibrate expectations. It isn't here. But, this is one of the best options I've had so far. They cook like they care and it doesn't taste like most of the half assed pizza down here. I've only had it delivered and it was pretty hot and quite good. I was pleasantly surprised. It isn't Ny pizza but for florida, this is a very good option. Never been to restaurant so I can't comment.

  • *****

    Wow is all I can say. I didn't expect to find a gem in a small hole in the wall. I love Brooklyn boys pizza they have very good pizza and strombilies. The deal breaker for me is always the crust on a pie. both of which have a thin crust that is cooked perfectly, not burnt and not under cooked and doughy. I would highly recommend Brooklyn Boys to eat. Or giving it to a loved one who is from ny... good memories always get brownie points.

  • *****

    Ordered a X-LARGE plain cheese pie last night and had it delivered... it was probably the best pizza I've had anywhere in Boca in quite some time. I was VERY surprised and extremely happy with it. My previous review of this place was only 2 stars because thats legitimately how I felt, but after last night's experience its definitely moving up! I'll try them again, and if its consistently as good as it was last night, I'll move up and give them the 5 stars, but for now, based on their overall performance, I think 4 stars is more than fair! :)

  • *****

    I love this place. So far it's been about the best pizza I have found in this part of florida. Each time I have had it it's been consistantly great. The crust is this and crusty and the toppings are usually fresh. Try them.

  • *****

    a

  • *****

    I like to consider myself, at the very least, knowledgeable about pizza and what makes a pizza great as opposed to just good. My parents are from the tri-state area, and my dad considers himself a bit of a pizza aficionado as well, so I've had a fair amount of experience. When I was younger he took me to the original Ray's in New York (The legitimately real Ray's, not one of the billions of copycats) and I have to say Brooklyn Boys knocks them out of the park.

    You walk in and it's by no means the most impressive looking place in the world. The sitting area is kind of small, the tables have seen better days, it's a textbook definition of a hole-in-the-wall. You know, like every great pizza place should be. Besides, once you've taken that first bite, the world around you melts away (much like the cheese). You've been transferred to a state of pizza Nirvana, a Valhalla of crispy crust, a Shangri-La of robust sauce, Heaven in a pie. Each bite is inexplicably better than the last. And then you realize that you've had the greatest pizza ever, and life is good again.

    That's why you should eat at Brooklyn Boys.

  • *****

    Excellent pizza.
    Dopey teenagers behind the counter.
    But very excellent pizza.

  • *****

    One of the best Pizzas I have had out side of Brooklyn!! The place is a bit small but definitely gives you a feeling that you are in NY .... loud and noisy at times! Yo.. Yo ... yous talking to me ..... :-) Will be back!

  • *****

    EASILY THE BEST TOMATO BASIL PIZZA EVER! They are Fast and reasonably priced. I love to run in there for a quick bite amongst errands. this joint is hassle free but parking in that Plaza can be disastrous! Snow bird warning: the Pizza place can fill up fast and leave you seatless because - The Snow Bird's need their fix of NY style Cheesy goodness!

    All in all, this place never let's me down because their Tomato Basil pizza can not be compared! Delicious!

  • *****

    hands down the closest thing to a New York slice in FLorida. 2 slices and a fountain coke with ice brings me back to my youth,

  • *****

    This was my first time here and it brought back a lot of memories from when I was a kid up north. I used to love going to the corner pizza place for lunch.

  • *****

    It was time I updated this review. My feelings about their pie hasn't change, it's still one of the best in the area. But I can't ignore the fact this place is run entirely by douches. Every one there minus the pie maker is an insufferable d-bag. The burnout kids taking the orders are lazy, unmotivated and unfriendly. The little weasel owner is always outside either on the phone or doing something that looks shady as hell. Never a smile. Not one thank you in all the years. I know this has nothing to do with the pizza, but I'm funding this place with ever order I make and that's an awful lot over the years. It's why I've started to branch out and go to places like Stellas, where you're literally treated like royalty the moment you step foot inside. I don't need anyone to slob my knob when I order a pizza pie, but at least pretend like you appreciate the business.

    Also, can people stop ordering anything other than pizza from joints like these? I read a few people talk about their chicken wings. Stop it. You're being a little silly there. Unless you're at a Tucci's or Anthonys, don't be ordering chicken wings at these take-out places. Go to a wing place if you want wings (Chez Porky, Hurricane, Brus). Just because a place has great pizza doesn't always mean they'll have great everything else.

    In closing, I'll still stand my claim about them being the best (at least one of in Boca), but I won't be ordering weekly because I feel like I'm funding douchbags which is no different than funding terrorists or like buying a Justin Bieber cd.

  • *****

    Was taking my kids to tutti fruttie as usual for yogurt and saw this pizza place. I didnt eat dinner yet so I figured the kids can get yogirt and ill just get a slice of pizza. Omg..that one slice turned out to be 3 slices. I ordered the mozzarella basil and it was the best that I had! The cheese was perfect the crust was hot and crunchy...dont know how to explain but it was the best...will only order there for pizza from now on!

  • *****

    We decided after a long weekend just to bring in a pie for dinner. We ordered a large pie, half mushroom & half plain. The pizza looked & smelled delicious. I like my pizza to be thin, crispy & saucy. The pizza was very good but not exceptional. The crust was thicker than most places that claim to make a thin crust. I also feel that they could have put a little more sauce on the pie. I thought the pizza had good flavor & probably would have enjoyed it more if there was a bit more sauce on it. I will return because it really was good but I will make a note to ask for extra sauce. My favorite pizza is still Stella's which is just right down the road. Brooklyn Boys is now my second favorite for when I want a good slice.

  • *****

    Best pizza around. Can't help but keep coming back. Good NY Style pizza. Nice family run store front. Yummmm

  • *****

    The girlfriend and I decided to try something new, and ordered a pizza from this place. The delivery was quick. From the call until it was at my door was probably 30-35 minutes. For a Saturday night, not too shabby.

    The food came piping hot. It reminded me of real NY/NJ pizza, or at least as close as you can get in FL. The toppings were generous. And over all, it was a damn good pizza. Probably one of the best I had tried in a while.

    If you're in West Boca, and want a good pizza, this is a must try.

  • *****

    Best pizza in Boca Raton. Definitely worth the price tag especially since it cannot compare to the typical pizza chain restaurants. It's so much better. And all the guys that work there are really nice.

  • *****

    Ok this isn't a NY pizza but it comes pretty close!! Just ordered a thin crust 5-topping pie and it was great. Crust was thin and crispy, toppings generous and delivery time right what they tell you. The best NY style pie in Boca. Better be, this is the 6th borough... Btw, if you like garlic add it as an additional topping, delicious! Little pricey compared to the average pizza but well worth it. Bon apetito!!

  • *****

    Really great pizza in the Boca area. I like the sauce and the crust is crispy. I had no problems with my take out order and the service couldn't of been better. Although, I prefer garlic knots instead of garlic buns, they were fresh and warm. Much better choice than commercial pizza delivery joints. I highly recommend this place and will return.

  • *****

    Moved here two weeks ago and have already ordered twice. Delicious pizza. I'm not from NY, but based on what I know NY style pizza to be, this seems very authentic. We absolutely loved it. Yummmmm

  • *****

    Nice NY style, decent sized slices, $15 for 5 and a soda, light on sauce and cheese, very Upper East Side slice style!

  • *****

    The best pizza I have had so far in Boca but the wings are nothing special. Would order from them again

  • *****

    Really good NY style pizza take out place.

    Located in an out parcel next to the Starbucks in Shadowood, BB's has been serving pizza to West Boca for years.

    There are about 5 or so tables inside and some outdoor seating, but this is mostly a take out place, so don't expect anything fancy. What you can expect is really good pizza. Their white pizza and Margarita are very good. However, the pizza here does taste slightly better at the restaurant than for take out, but ask for it to be a bit more done and this should keep it crispy.

    Yes, the main chef is a bit ornery, but the rest of the staff I have always found to be friendly. Anyway, I don't come here for the service, I come here their delicious pizza.

    Have and will come back.

  • *****

    One of the only places in the area to grab slices. Pizza is one of the best in Boca. Chicken parm sub is great. Recommend if looking for fast service, quick delivery, and good food.

  • *****

    Great pizza. Never any coupons or specials though. Their pizza is so good that they don't have to.

  • *****

    Awesome pizza with great options for a fair price. Meat lovers is definitely one to keep in mind!

  • *****

    Awesome food. Nice and friendly service. Best pizza in a 50 mile radius. Wings were big and juicy, crust nice and crispy and the sandwich suculent and tasty.

  • *****

    Amazing!!! Baked ziti is so good... Pizza is delish and garlic rolls are amazing!
    Really good and highly recommended!

  • *****

    The only reason why this is not getting 5 stars is becuz I am from Chicago and luv Chicago pizza. This pizza is phenomenal as well as the garlic knots. Service is great and friendly. I highly recommend this pizzeria

  • *****

    Only had a meatball park at lunchtime, but the meatballs were delicious- just like my Sicilian aunt used to make.
    I will definitely come back to try the pizza.

    Only drawback- the place is small and not a lot of seating. Plan to pickup and take home.

  • *****

    Love this place. Great food always consistent. Feels like eating at a pizza shop up North. Would pick Brooklyn Boys over the chain store any day.

  • *****

    My favorite pizza in Boca Raton. Same great taste for 10 years- hasn't changed!! Can't say that about most places.

  • *****

    Don't believe the other pizzerias around here when you're looking for NY style pizza. Brooklyn Boys has the best and never disappoints. You walk through the door and you can smell the authenticity. My daughter and I love it! Can't judge their other food items though since the pizza is all we ever want.

  • *****

    Going here for 15 years. Grew up in Brooklyn so I know my pizza. This is the best Boca Raton has to offer and maybe all of south Florida. Extra large crispy pies and fantastic Sicilian. Best baked ravioli and garlic rolls. Free delivery. Go for it.

  • *****

    I always order to-go. The pizza is delivered in 45 min to an hour. When I call it's super busy and loud so the employee can never hear me. Pizza always comes fresh to my door and exactly as ordered. Prices are reasonable!!!

  • *****

    So far this place has the best pizza around and their breadsticks are awesome very buttery and garlicky. Everybody in the business seems very nice and delivery is quick solid choice

  • *****

    Great pizza and quick delivery!!! We are new to the area and have been looking for good pizza. So happy we found this place.

  • *****

    Love their Sicilian pizza. Light and crispy. It's the best. The right amount of sauce and cheese make it my favorite

  • *****

    This is more of a to go place in my opinion. It's very small inside so if you're looking for a real sit down restaurant feel, this may not be it. For a cute casual dining experience, I recommend.

    I'm reviewing based on a plain slice of cheese pizza. It's the only thing I've had and probably the only thing I'll get. You can easily walk in and get a slice in less than 2 minutes.

    It's quick, easy, and delicious. The employees are also really friendly.

  • *****

    This was an awesome surprise. I've lived in Boca for only 2 weeks, and stumbled on this gem when I got done in Best Buy. I was craving a couple of slices of good pizza and this place appeared. I was born and raised in Brooklyn NY. The pizza is awesome. I'll be coming back again to try more of their delicious food.

  • *****

    This place is delicious! The store is small but the taste is huge! Indoor and outdoor seating are both available. I had a slice of cheese pizza, hubby had sausage and onion. We ordered an Italian hoagie to share and everything was cooked to perfection! Incredible! Honestly the best sub and sauce I've had in Boca Raton!

  • *****

    Love this place! I don't miss NY! Their pizza has a nice thin crispy crust ! They also make great Sicilians hmm good!

  • *****

    Good pizza!! Just like we have in Brooklyn, NY. Just wish it's bigger place so much smokes if sitting inside

  • *****

    Is this the best pizza I ever had? No.

    Is this some damn good pizza. Absolutely. The crust is very thin, just how I like it, representing the NY(and NJ) style of pizza. The flavor doesn't overpower, although I do love and appreciate robust flavor on something as simple as pizza, and the cheese has a nice smooth texture.

    I find the pepperoni and/or sausage is great here. I can't give much detail to other menu items as I haven't tried. However I will update as time passes as I partake in other menu items.

  • *****

    Best pizza I've had in Boca. Been there many times and always tastes good. Quick friendly service.

  • *****

    This is the best Pizza in the Area... [Drop Microphone, exit stage]

    Got to say something more or it's a tip, but there is nothing more to say...

  • *****

    Still the very best but does both TV's have be on Fox ?
    Can't one be MSNBC or CNN for the other 60% of your customers

  • *****

    For me this is the best pizza place in town. You have to try the Tomato and Basil pizza which is why I come back.

  • *****

    Been going here for awhile love there pizza alittle pricey but worth the money . Nice sitting area out front as well. The employee's could have better customer service, but i dont come their for hospitality i go for the pizza

  • *****

    A very good slice. Place is small and casual with minimal seating and no real decor, but for a quick lunch or snack it hits the spot.

  • *****

    This place was great. Pizza was amazing. Spaghetti and eggplant were also incredible. I can't wait to go back. The most unique thing is that any one of the 5 or 6 guys behind the counter could kick your butt, but they were so friendly and cool to my wife and kids. Great spot. Thank you

  • *****

    We found this little gem on accident. They make the best pizza we have had since we have been in Florida. We now plan our shopping around them so we can stop by for a slice. The place is clean and the people are very friendly. I think you can call us regulars now.

  • *****

    Brooklyn Boys Pizza is the best pizza I've ever had since Living in Florida. I've been in Florida since 2000, I've never had pizza in Florida that was up to par with NY until I had Brooklyn Boys Pizza. I'm from Queens, NY, the pizza at Brooklyn Boys equally matches up to NY. The employees at Brooklyn Boys are always paying attention to the customer, everybody helps. Typical NY. Thanks for the amazing pizza that I just had a few moments ago and for always making the perfect slice.

  • *****

    The best pizza south of NY city. The extra large white pizza is the best I ever had. Great service

  • *****

    The taste of home! A bit out if our way but my parents dont live too far from here and we just had to stop by. Absolutely DID NOT disappoint. Small place but the pizza is so worth it!

  • *****

    Small shop with a couple of tables inside. Pizza was good and not greasy. Wait time was good, so it should be a good place to stop by, order and take out on the speedy side.

  • *****

    This restaurant is definitely one of the best in this area. ?

  • *****

    Great New York style thin crust pizza.

  • *****

    Good tasty pizza with an excellent crust. Highly recommended.

  • *****

    Great pizza

  • *****

    Great pizza by the slice. Always in and our with NO PROBLEMS

  • *****

    Great Pizza and friendly staff!! Carlos the owner, knows how to run his place...The food is fresh and delicious!! Going back soon!!..Thanx!!

  • *****

    This place is the bomb and their pizza rules. It's quite cheap and the people are zany and nice.. I?ve tried almost all their pizza and it was amazing. Moral of the story? Get over your love of McDonalds and stick with these guys. They're legit. THANKS :D

  • *****

    I love this place! The food is really good and reasonably priced. Their pizza is great! The atmosphere is really good gives you a nice feeling...

Select language to translate this page: